Skip Main Navigation
Share this page
22 October 2026
Diversity, disparity and inclusion Practicalities of being a magistrate

For Black History Month, which runs throughout October, we spoke to some of our Black members to understand more about why representation matters in the court room.

Above from left: Abbay Dada, Kate Donkor, Christopher Crawford.

This year’s Black History Month theme is Honouring Our Communities; urging us to celebrate everyday individuals and organisations that support, sustain, and strengthen Black communities across Britain.  

As judicial office holders, all magistrates play a vital role in the delivery of fair and timely justice for their communities, but for Black, Asian and global majority magistrates, their presence on the Bench can carry an additional significance – representation. 

Kate Donkor sits in London. She says: “Being a Black magistrate is both a privilege and a responsibility. It means being able to contribute to the facilitation of justice while bringing my own life experience, perspective and understanding of the communities I serve.” 

Abbay Dada of Buckinghamshire tells us: “Being a Black magistrate is a source of pride, purpose and responsibility. I bring my lived experience to the Bench, while remaining independent, impartial and guided by the evidence and the law. I am also conscious of being visible in a role where Black people have historically been underrepresented.”  

Meanwhile, Sarah Sawyerr, who also sits in London, says: “I am not just a Black magistrate.  I am a Magistrate that happens to be Black. In the same way that I am a magistrate that happens to be a woman. Being Black does not affect my decision-making process. However, being a Black woman with my lived experience, does inform who I am.”  

It’s a core principle that magistrates should reflect the communities they serve. The latest Diversity of the Judiciary statistics show that nationally, five per cent of magistrates are Black. In London, this figure sits at 14 per cent – far higher than the national average. These figures have increased over the last decade, as recruitment looks to make the magistracy more accessible for all. 

Everton Paisley sits in Norfolk and became a magistrate two years ago, having previously served as a police officer. He says: “I am extremely proud to call myself a magistrate and thoroughly enjoy being part of a team of fellow magistrates from diverse backgrounds. In my early years as a police officer, magistrates were mainly privileged white, middle-aged men. It was extremely rare to see a fully diverse Bench in terms of gender and ethnicity.” 

Christopher Crawford, who sits on the Surrey Bench, says: “Our communities are diverse and made up of people with different experiences, cultures and perspectives. A magistracy that reflects this diversity can help maintain public confidence in the justice system. While every magistrate is committed to fairness and impartiality, it is important that people can see that those entrusted with administering justice come from all parts of society.” 

Newly appointed Northamptonshire magistrate Mo Hussein agrees, telling us that “People should be able to see that those administering justice come from all parts of society. Different backgrounds bring valuable perspectives, while every magistrate shares the same responsibility to act impartially and uphold the law.” 

What does this look like in practice? Kate says: “There have been moments (in the court room) when I have become particularly conscious that people are not simply seeing a magistrate; they are seeing someone who may reflect a community or experience that they recognise. 

Sometimes it is something as simple as the way someone engages with you through body language, such as a look or expression. Those moments remind me that representation can have an impact even when nothing is said explicitly.” 

Sarah thinks about a time when she was sitting as a winger in front of a young Black defendant. She says: “When we went out to discuss the matter the Presiding Justice (PJ) mentioned that the young man was only focusing on me during the proceedings. When we went back in the PJ invited me to lead on the questions. He felt that the defendant had made a connection with me on the Bench and felt it would be more impactful if I addressed him directly.”

Christopher notes that “while I cannot know how individuals perceive the Bench, I hope that seeing magistrates from different backgrounds helps reinforce the message that the justice system is inclusive and representative of the communities it serves.” 

Asked what he would say to someone from the Black community who has never considered becoming a magistrate, Mo says: “Explore the opportunity. Your life experience, judgement and commitment to fairness could make a valuable contribution. You do not need a legal background, and you should feel that there is a place for you on the Bench.” 

Everton says: “As we now live in a multi-cultural society, I would explain to the person that the justice system can only be successful if it is comprised of magistrates that truly represent society in terms of diverse backgrounds and ethnic origins.” He adds that there is a fully comprehensive training package available and highlights the importance of the mentor/mentee relationship. 

Abbay tells people not to rule themselves out: “The role requires preparation before each court sitting, but the pride of serving your community and contributing to decisions that affect people’s lives, including children’s welfare, far outweighs the effort.” 

Finally, Kate says: “Joining the magistracy is one of the best experiences I have embarked on – every time I sit on the Bench, I learn from my fellow colleagues and relish the opportunity to make a difference. 

“If you have ever wondered whether someone like you could sit on the Bench, my answer would be, ‘yes, you can’! Perhaps one day, someone else will look at you on that Bench and realise that they can too.”